Mafia AG: The Villagers DT [GG]

[VivaLaDementia]

.__.? You teach your assassins to kill off randoms/inactives?
However, I do admit I am suspicious of Noex off how he has replied today. Though I did not consider it enough for a lynch.

 

[Lily]

:0 woow that 'random' voting killed off Nico :0 Chimer being killed off is random.. :/ well at least we something to go with today~ a little more than yesterday :3

/lol'sattheviva/noexconvo

Y lynch the gm? Rather pointless..

 

[noex1337]

Ehhhhhh, I just realized i look hypocritical if I invite people to play the game and then i just screw around, so I'll stop that.

 

[Emeralda]

You look hypocrytical when you invite people and don't post anything serious. But who am I to judge, I can't think of anything interesting to post either.

 

[noex1337]

Quite honestly, there's not much to talk about. Lynch moi because she never changed her vote, or lynch you because you sheeped it. Or maybe lynch me because i want to kill the GM, what else is there?

 

[VivaLaDementia]

That is true, however the lack of discussion has caused no solution to our lynch problem. So those topics should still be discussed until we reach a conclusion. Though, to be fair, its hard for you and Emmie to discuss those topics when you are the subject of said topics.

 

[noex1337]

Then let's make it fair, lynch you because you're so adamant about lynching someone in general. After all, the only one that benefits from mindless killings are the villagers. Now we're all suspicious.

 

[VivaLaDementia]

Well thats just piss-poor reasoning. I have presented reasons to why you and moi are suspicious (Excluding Emmie because I don't believe her to be suspicious right now).
I did not force anyone to follow my logic, I only discouraged stupid choices (aka Lynching the GM) and I merely offered choices I believed was valid.

Your post there just makes it seem like you are discouraging any kind of public suspicion and discourage players from voicing their views. Your really not doing yourself any favors in my eyes right now.

 

[noex1337]

Never planned to do any sort of favors in your eyes. But you're skirting the fact. Suspicion is one thing. We all have suspicion, that's how we play the game. You however seem to be looking for any death, to go as far as call a lynch on me because it would be "more productive". There's not much reasoning there at all, and it looks like you just want someone dead. The only reason i'm not thinking too hard on this is because it's opposite of what you said yesterday, but that's still not convincing enough.

Some quotes for reference:

I don't care who moi is, that means a lynch for me until someone gives me real proof someone else is guilty.

Screw it, who wants to lynch noex? More productive then lynching them GM at least

 

[VivaLaDementia]

The last post was a joke, I figured the "Screw it" was an indication of that. Notice - How no one believed it + I never changed my vote.
I also am not after a lynch on you, or at least as of now (Since each post you make just makes me more suspicious of you at this point, because of what your saying). I specifically said that earlier as well.

As for moi, thats very true. I have a history of sometimes lynching players who I believe are dangerous, even if they could be good. Not dangerous as a baddies threat or someone I believe will threaten my views/logic, but rather dangerous as in potential to do more harm to the goodies side. Ask Johnzy, I've done it to him before. Doesn't mean I'm not suspicious of the player I'm lynching, it typically does mean I'm very suspicious of them - But that comment I made was to say that I fell no regret if said player (In this case moi) dies and turns out to be a goodie. As far as I'm concerned, moi forfeited the right for any sympathy on Day 1 when they killed Nico. Thats what I was trying to say.

Now your bringing up a point I already addressed. Not to mention others have agreed with me. Different days are different situations which means different responses. What part of that do you not understand? Or did you expect me to be against the lynch every single day for the entire AG? Thats just ridiculous.

 

[noex1337]

Well, that's about all I have to contribute to this discussion. Although I will ask, why was chimer's kill revealed? I'm asking under the assumption that there is a janitor-equivalent role on the mafia side like last mafia game.

 

[VivaLaDementia]

There might not be a janitor in this game. Tbh the only time I've ever seen the janitor was in Crestham's last AG, so its not something common at all.

 

[noex1337]

I saw one in another simple game on MF, so i assumed it was a staple for simple games.

 

[VivaLaDementia]

Yeah, but that was also TRC taking all the roles from the wiki without any thinking involved. Her game was basically a carbon copy of Crestham's game, which was taken from the wiki.
This time might not be the same, but we can't judge for now since there were only 2 activities yesterday, one of which being the lynch and the other being the villager's kill.

 

[moi]

here to defend myself, I guess. I stated in this thread before I voted that my choice would be random. I suppose I should have realized that with so little action in the voting thread any lead would be sheeped.

 

[VivaLaDementia]

Well I guess you haven't paid any attention to the voting thread then. Since no one actually sheeped your vote (there were 2 extra votes on Nico, but for others reasons I believe). Your vote was enough to kill Nico.
So, care to explain why you randomly picked a player to die?

Also - [MENTION=1507]Geoff[/MENTION] [MENTION=171]Notorious[/MENTION]
Anything to say? I can't talk for everyone now and I know how much we all hate lurkers~

 

[Notorious]

[MENTION=192]moi[/MENTION] you could have always cast a no-vote. After all, the general consensus was set this way at the time, I think.

What bothers me more than the fact you voted for her is that you did not edit it afterwards. Ofc, no-one can force you, but I think maybe you should have...

 

[noex1337]

Didn't check the thread maybe? Did anyone mention her?

 

[VivaLaDementia]

[MENTION=66]Lightning[/MENTION] [MENTION=160]Queen Elizardbeth[/MENTION]
Both of you have no posts. Do you not like to talk with us D:

[MENTION=47]Ray[/MENTION] [MENTION=1312]placa_placa[/MENTION]
Both of you have 1 post. Did we say something to scare you away? (Didn't include Auron because he specifically mentioned he wouldn't be posting much yesterday)

 

[Geoff]

Also - [MENTION=1507]Geoff[/MENTION]

Can't I have some time to think?
Noex runs off to kill the host, you run off to kill moi because she lynched a goodie yesterday, and now hunt down Noex because he's muckracking, and havoc is being played like a fiddle.
I see why you want to vote for them, but I don't agree that's the right person to vote. We only get one vote a day, let's use it on something more then the host, or "He's annoying."

I'm scanning the thread to see how people posted, and maybe figure who's not as mafiaish as they say they are. If and when I vote, I'll make sure to explain just why.


Also, Everyone close your eyes please.
Everyone not reading this? Great!
Especially you mimic. >.>
...


Aidan, I'm a

Ok, your turn now :3