Icon Battle! [Voting]

Status
Not open for further replies.
#1
Icon Battle!



Challengers:

Lovely. & Wwgeaf



Themes:

Axis Powers Hetalia

Music

Bleach

Real Life



2 Entries per Theme







Entries



#1 ----------------- #2



Axis Powers Hetalia

|


Stock -------- Stock ----|---- Stock -------- Stock







Music

|


Stock -------- Stock ----|---- Stock -------- Stock







Bleach

|


Stock -------- Stock ----|---- Stock -------- Stock







Real Life

|


Stock -------- Stock ----|---- Stock -------- Stock







Remember, you can only vote for 1 entry! Voting for an entry means you vote for all the 8 icons the entrant has submitted.



Voting will last 1 week.







 

~Kitty~

Kitty pawns all!
#2
I vote for entry 1 on the music theme.

Also from that I think I can tell that the same person did an SOTW entry..lol..



@hades hi dad.
 
#3
[quote name='Graham Aker']I vote for entry 1 on the music theme.

Also from that I think I can tell that the same person did an SOTW entry..lol..



@hades hi dad.[/QUOTE]



You're supposed to vote for all the themes. If you vote #1, you vote for all the 8 entries under #1, spanning the 4 themes.
 

~Kitty~

Kitty pawns all!
#5
[quote name='Hadriel']



You're supposed to vote for all the themes. If you vote #1, you vote for all the 8 entries under #1, spanning the 4 themes.
[/QUOTE]



Can I vote individually for each theme?



cause I kinda like different works from each theme...



2

1

2

1

thats how I liked it....
 
#6
[quote name='Graham Aker']Can I vote individually for each theme?



cause I kinda like different works from each theme...



2

1

2

1

thats how I liked it....[/QUOTE]



No, you can't.
 

VivaLaDementia

Yea, Its been a ride...
#8
In the end I voted #2.



It was spilt 2 vs 2 for me, when I went down by each theme, however person 2 did comparatively better in the themes that they won, so I went with them.

For the record:

Axis Powers Hetalia - Person 1

Music - Person 2

Bleach - Person 1

Real Life - Person 2



Only time Person 1 won was because Person 2 overkilled their icons with too many effects for my liking.
 
#11
[quote name='"Graham Aker"']hmm I guess number 2 GMV then



Next time maybe and odd number of entries so there cant be a tie. XD[/QUOTE]



Well, it was their decision to do it this way, so I can't stop it,
 

dark_9tails

dark_9tailsノ(ಥ益ಥノ)
#14
2

2

1

1



Overall #2 GMV, since I think the gfxer spent some time on doing the effects. But one suggestion to the #2 gfxer: You could have chosen stocks of only one person in them, to prevent overcrowding in the icons. Or maybe make icons which only fit the face of one person? That way it makes us easier to see their faces. :]
 

Lily

Dead is the new alive.
#15
#2 Gets my vote~

It was pretty neck to neck with the first three themes but it was the fourth theme (real life) that made the decision.
 

Maria.

→Donut Vampire
#16
#2 GMV.



Why?

All of 1 has redundant color schemes.

All of 2 has non redundant color schemes but somehow dull.



I'd pick non-redundant color scheme entries because you can see the effort the GFXer took in the colorisation of his/her works.. ^^



Short tip: The key to avoid dullness in saturated works is picking a good color>fill in a layer>and set to lighten only to balance the colors. ^^
 
#17
And after a week of voting, the winner of the Icon Battle is...




Entry #2





Lovely.



Congratulations on winning the battle!





Runner-up:



Entry #1





Wwgeaf





Great job, battlers!

 
Status
Not open for further replies.