SOTW #11 - Voting

[Shadow_Strider]

Entry #3 GMV, it's messy and could be improved but I like it and I actually like the color combination of Red and Sliver.

 

[dark_9tails]

I don't think it's a tie? ?__? (And I think I've made the votes a tie)

Anyway, #2 GMV. It's simple yet elegant. At first I thought the brown effects beside the render were clipping masks lol until I saw its stock @_@ Nonetheless, it's the most appealing tag among all and to me, it's very gothic indeed, what more the colours

Entry #1 almost had my vote. Except that it's too dark and the typo's a bit off.

Entry #3's not bad, though it lacks depth and the blue parts could have been colourised to a bit grayish/reddish.

 

[Hadriel]

I don't think it's a tie? ?__? (And I think I've made the votes a tie)

Oh yeah, you did. Crap.
Gotta find more voters!

 

[Placa]

#1 Seems like someone turned off the lights
#2 Everything blends in nicely but the text is barely visible
#3 Very good but it could stand to use less effects
#4 Doesn't seem to fit the theme very well.

So, Entry #3 GMV

 

[Devil Doll]

#2 GMV
It fits the theme best
i like the light settings~

 

[Misaka Mikoto]

Entry no. 2
I Like it and fits le theme
​

 

[Ferris]

entry #2 - its kewl~ really gothic~ and i love the effects ..

 

[noex1337]

I'm not too sure what the theme is. Is it gothic or lolita?
#1 GMV for now.

 

[Hadriel]

I'm not too sure what the theme is. Is it gothic or lolita?
#1 GMV for now.

It's Gothic Lolita.
[MENTION=164]noex1337[/MENTION]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lolita_fashion#Gothic_Lolita

 

[windborn]

#3 gets mine.

#1 second place.
#2 is too simple in my opinion, there's no background at all to speak of.
#4 is totally off the theme.

 

[Notorious]

Entry 2, but I think the background is slightly lacking (this is from a non-GFXer's point of view)

 

[Murasaki Cho]

#2 GMV
-simply gothic from all corner
-drawn my attention the most

 

[Canabary]

1. I like it, but it's a tad too dark IMO
2. Nice, but eh maybe a little plain and the render is slightly LQ...
3.I like it, but the render and the background blends in a ay I'm quit sure it's not supposed to (part of the render becomes more or less invisible).
4.Render sort of appears to be floating on top of a background. The background in itself is nice, although it lacks a colour spectrum,

All in all fairly good submissions. My vote goes to number 1 though.